Birth Statistics

join us on facebook

follow us on twitter


South Coast Calmbirth Coast KidsAdvertise Here
Home :: Blog :: Stories :: Twin Home Water Birth — Justine Caines

Twin Home Water Birth — Justine Caines

Majella Clare and Rosie Patricia – 6 December 2005

40 weeks + 1 (3kg & 3.1kg)

Justine Caines is the former secretary of Homebirth Australia and a respected advocate of natural birth. She gave birth to twins at home in December 2005, and tells their story below. Justine has also written an article on risk and birth which elaborates on her informed decision to plan a homebirth for her twins.

justineAt 18 weeks I attended a routine GP appointment in order to have a blood screen and get a referral for an ultrasound (even though I had not decided if I was having one).  I was planning another homebirth (all my 4 children have been born at home).  These experiences have been the most exquisite of my life and I would only birth in hospital if proven to be absolutely medically necessary.

The GP asked if he could feel my belly and I agreed.  He said I was presenting higher than my dates. I quickly replied that “I was certain of my dates” and he then said he would put the scanner on  (which was a very small unit that I had not noticed at the end of the bed).  ”Just as I suspected he said”.  ”What?” I replied nervously fearing a problem.  He then said, “See that little one” and although it was small and birdlike it was surprisingly clear.  ”Yes” I said.  He then moved the scanner to the left and said, “Well there´s another”.  At this stage I believe I reinacted the shampoo commercial where the woman becomes hysterical.  I left in a daze forgetting to pay or have my blood test! I already had 4 children and the idea of 6 aged 6 and under was a little daunting.

My pregnancy progressed without real incident I was happy and healthy.  I was quite nervous about growing 2 little people (I was confident about 1 but 2 was different).  I had an anterior placenta and did not feel either baby until 22 weeks, and then one baby was far less active (due to the position of the placenta).

My plans for a homebirth were undeterred.  I did however choose to have the 3 ultrasounds recommended by an Obstetrician I trusted, one at 20 weeks, 28 wks and 34 wks.  This was the only interaction I had with medical care.  We found that the babies each had their own sac and which was a good thing (no chance of them entangling in each others cords).  Like all our babies we chose not to find out their gender. The ultrasound also provided a crude weight estimate (as ultrasound is only accurate + or – 20%) but it was useful, as we knew the estimate was similar for each baby.

I put on very little weight and close to the end of my pregnancy felt that I was ‘all babies’.  Despite some wonderful advice to rest everyday I was unable to do this (with 4 other children!). Perhaps stupidly our family also moved house when I was 35 weeks pregnant!  Some of those close to me feared that this might bring on the babies.  I was quietly confident and told them they needed to wait so they could be born in their home free of boxes and wait for their brothers and sister to calm down from the big move.

Sadly the greatest challenge was finding 2 midwives to support me to have twins at home.  Unfortunately I also have the extra impediment of living in rural NSW.  I needed to find 2 midwives that would travel to me and support my choice to birth twins at home.  I did not find these 2 angels until I was 34 weeks pregnant.  Betty Vella and Robyn Gasparotto not only had the courage to truly be ‘with woman´ they also drove 600 kms round trip for each visit.  Well and truly beyond the call of duty I would say! When we all met I felt an instant calm and knew all would be fine.

By 38 weeks I thought I might meet by babies.  Although I refuse to accept obstetric hysteria and fear mongering there is a pervasive view that few women get to 40 weeks with twins.  Also it is a very common practice for women to be induced at 38 weeks.  My midwives had faith however and were game enough to say they thought my body would grow these babies to 40 weeks!!! (My bladder heaved at this comment).  My pregnancy was really beautiful, my back held up well and even the nagging symphis pubis pain of previous pregnancies was seldom felt.  My bladder did however feel the pressure of the additional weight.  I only got up once per night however (from about 30 wks).

Like many women I felt fed up and ready to give birth and around 38 and a half weeks.  I had a lot of pressure on the cervix in these last weeks (obviously doing great preparatory work for labour).  As I approached 40 weeks most people (other than my faithful midwives) were astounded I could ‘go this far!  The mindset that twins come early is firmly ingrained. The fact that the vast majority of women giving birth in the system are pressured into unnecessary induction at 38 weeks gives weight to this perception!

On the Sunday evening we decided to watch a DVD, ‘Meet the Fockers´ (something I would never watch!!).  I found it so funny that I believe I laughed my waters to breaking point!  It was a hind water leak, but as I had also had a ‘show´ that day I called my midwives.  They had to travel from Sydney (4hrs) and I wanted them to be with me in time.  For someone who wanted a ‘sign´ to forewarn us, this proved to be it.  Both midwives and my friend and doula, Margie Perkins arrived in the wee hours of the morning.  I slept through their arrivals and woke at 8.30am feeling like a huge fraud, nothing had happened!!!

The next day was very hot and with 4 young children I knew nothing would happen in the day.  Betty and Robyn did some wonderful reflexology, massaging the point in the foot for the uterus and massaging a relevant pressure point on the inside of the ankle.  This worked well, giving me some nice tightenings. We shared a nice meal and all went to bed.  My midwives were very confident that it would happen that night. On reflection this was a lovely time as Margie, Betty and Robyn got to meet and we all shared a day (kids included), before our babies arrived.

At 1.30am I awoke to the horn of the freight train passing through and a huge gush of waters.  15 minutes later my first contraction, and boy was it real.  I only waited for another 2 before waking the three wise women.  I was conscious that we needed to fill the pool and that would take an hour.  As I predicted once labour started it really ‘kicked in´.  Within 30 minutes I could feel our first baby moving right down and that pressure on my tail.  I have birthed 4 children standing up and yet I have always wanted a waterbirth.  When it came to labour I was not comfortable sitting or kneeling.  I still clung to the water idea, as I so much wanted to ‘catch´ my own baby. Interestingly this time I found it very intense in my usually preferred standing position leaning on the kitchen bench.

As soon as the pool was nearly full enough to give birth I got in.  The pain relief was amazing. I kneeled and lent over the side (the pool was semi rigid with a support ledge around it, perfect!)  Our photo record reveals I was only in the pool for 7 minutes before B1 (Majella) arrived.  To my astonishment I calmly placed my hand on her soft little head and felt her shoulders rotate before being totally born into my determined arms! I lifted her up and welcomed her (without knowing her sex).  I was overjoyed to have a girl (after 3 boys in a row) and a photo captured my expression.  It looked like agony but it was ecstasy!

Majella´s cord was not overly long.  Very soon after her birth I began contracting with B2.  My husband, Paul got into the pool to hold Majella.  Although he was very gentle I found it very hard to contract with a baby still attached.  The cord had stopped pulsating so I asked that it be cut.  Our daughter, Ruby cut the cord.  I got on with birthing B2.  Betty announced that she ‘saw a foot´.  B2 was in a breech position all of my pregnancy.  At about 38 weeks we thought she had turned.  I never felt a movement and was not surprised to hear she was still breech.  I remember thinking “oh this bit will be easy but I´ll then have to brace myself for the head”.  I know I had just birthed a baby but I must say this birth was very easy. Betty gently moved Rosie toward me (so she didn´t bob up behind me as her head was last and the weight would of naturally taken her behind me not in front) and I again received my baby.  Rosie was born 13 minutes after Majella.  She was very alert and in good condition for a breech babe.  She took a couple more minutes to be calm (compared to Majella) but was essentially fine from the moment of birth.  I gently welcomed her and soon after started a very literal motherhood ‘juggle´ as I held a baby in each arm.  At this stage I said, “I don´t know which way to look”.  What an amazingly gentle and beautiful experience.  The room was full of warmth and love.  What an end to our birthing experiences.  What a triumph to be holding two babies that I had caught myself.

I wanted to change positions to birth the placentae (two placentas fused).  I actually had another few good contractions before I birthed it. I was surprised that this was quite hard work! As planned it was a physiological third stage.  I had minimal blood loss, less I believe than with some of my other children.

My recovery has been extraordinary. I felt healthy and strong, a bit of a bonus as I embarked on feeding twins and caring for 4 other children!

The birth of Majella and Rosie was very straightforward and beautiful as I imagined.  Essentially it was no big deal; Just a wonderful family event. When we take a look at what my options would have been if I had birthed in hospital one realises it was extraordinary in its ordinariness.  I am so very grateful to my midwives for enabling this. In Hospital, at best if I was ‘allowed´ to birth vaginally I would have been pressured to have an induction at 38 weeks, with constant monitoring removing the ability to use my body to its best advantage of an active birth. I would also have been pressured to consent to an epidural and a forceps removal of the second twin.  Why?  Because of fear from medical practitioners who have no faith in birth being normal and women´s bodies having the innate ability to birth.

My dream of a water birth would have been right out the window, and as for our 6 year old cutting the cords! Wouldn´t the hippie detector have been in overdrive!

Recently I was in a major shopping centre and as I have learnt twins, especially month old one´s are fascinating to many.  A woman approached me and we started chatting. When I revealed that these were baby 5 and 6 she asked how the other children were.  I told her that they were all very happy, as birth was such a normal event in our house.  I told her that Ruby was present and cut both cords.  She was naturally surprised, but to my surprise she was really happy to hear such a positive story.  She left saying 
”What a wonderful bond Ruby will have with her sisters.  What a wonderful gift.”

Every birth is a gift, and they each teach us something.  I did not learn any more about the wonder and strength of a woman’s body (well perhaps a bit as I grew 2 babies!), this time I learnt of the amazing bond that surrounds birth.  The relationship between women, in what is so very much women’s business.

I do not underestimate the unfaltering love and support of my husband, Paul.  When I hear of how so many men try and control birth and have little faith in women´s power I am reminded of how lucky I am. This was the gift of our first birth.

So as I hang up my ‘birthing boots’ I will cherish the love and faith of what the word midwife means, “with woman”.  To Betty, Robyn, and Margie, Thank you for all the intangibles: the courage and wisdom to step outside the square.  Also for the very practical things, all the driving, and the time it took to support me through this wonderful journey.  The following quote sums up my 6 beautiful homebirths

Justine Caines

Somewhere ages and ages hence:
Two roads diverged in a wood, and I – I took the one less travelled by, And that has made all the difference.

Robert Frost- The Road Not Taken

Share and Enjoy:
  • Print
  • Digg
  • Facebook
  • MySpace
  • Technorati
  • Twitter
  • RSS
15 Responses to “Twin Home Water Birth — Justine Caines”
  1. Michelle

    A beautiful story Justine, what a calm and beautiful way to welcome your babies into the world.

  2. Annette Connor

    What a beautiful birthing story, it made me cry. Water is so relaxing for me, swimming in it, standing under it, just looking at it – it’s a great regret that I didn’t have water births for my children. I hope we can make home water births more available to Australian mothers in the future.
    You are an amazing woman – a bit crazy I think, but powerful nonetheless. Well done!

  3. Elena

    What a wonderful story! could I ask to get the contacts of those midwives. you were so confident with them and I’m looking for someone qiute urgently- next week I have either to make a deposit to the hospital (I’m not local and not covered for birth) either to stick with homebirth defenitely. The more I find out the less I want to go hospital. I’m 30 weeks, but the dates are not accurate. they say feb, i think – march, which means induction, and my previous baby I had 2,5 weeks later the due date. And also the baby now is in breech position and he might turn, but if he doesn’t- then that’s a definite cesarian, which is quite unacceptable for me. And in my country if I wanted to have the homebirth with the only birthcentre I’m confident in – then I had to take 6 months pregnancy course with them- too late and to travel, too. Hoping to get some advice. Thank you and all the best!

  4. Hello Elena

    That’s wonderful you are considering a home birth.

    You don’t mention what area you live in – here is Betty Vella’s contact details who was one of the midwives at Justine’s birth.

    Betty Vella
    Midwife Practitioner
    North Gymea NSW 2227
    Phone: (02) 9540 4992
    Mobile: 0410 504 992

    The best place to search for a midwife in your local area is here:

    or here:

    You can ask with your local homebirth organisation for midwife recommendations. These local organisations will be linked to from the map on the first website above.

    If your baby is breech, there are some care providers and hospitals who will support you to have a vaginal breech birth – such as John Hunter Hospital with Dr Andrew Bisits in Newcastle. Women travel from all over Australia to have their babies here.

    Good luck!

  5. kelly


    I just wanted to thank you for sharing your home water birth experience.

    It’s very reassuring to know that there are very strong, sensible and determined women out there.

    Both you and the midwifes who were so committed are an inspiration.

    I’m hoping to be able to water birth for number 4 at home in France after 2 “normal” home births and a “gentle” hospital birth in Melbourne.

    Internet makes the world seem like such a small likeminded place when other info sources make it feel so big and hostile.

    Thanks again for sharing your courageous story.
    Kind regards
    Kelly Villain

  6. Ann

    wow Justine, what a fantastic birth! i can imagine that the happy cocktail of hormones carried you on a high for a long time. I also had the incredible joy of catching my last baby (number 4). I think I didn’t stop smiling for at least 6 months, and the bond is extraordinary. I also get called a crazy hippy by most around me, but if it means i show my daughter how natural birth should be, so be it. good luck with your beautiful big family.

  7. Debbie Reichard

    Firstly thanks for your story and your example – they say that beginnings have a magic and a madness to them – maybe there is an element of both in any birth especially home birth. Thank you also for being such a powerful exponent to the home birth movement here in Australia. I hope that along with the support there is in the community (albeit low in actual numbers)
    there is such a force and motivation to allow women to make their own choices and not be strapped to convention and the seemingly endless interventive minds of so many in the medical field. Power to the women !

  8. Lalita

    Hi Justine,
    After speaking with you today i thought i would read your birthing story. Wow!!! what an amazing story it was. The power, connectedness and courage of women never seizes to amaze me. I had the biggest smile on my face as i was reading and a flood of memories came back to me. My water birth baby will be 17 this year and it only seems like yesterday when she came swimming like a little tadpole towards me,poked her little head up above the water and took her first breath.She looked into my eyes, followed the voices, looked at all the faces around her and then promptly attached herself to my right breast. This was to become her favourite position for the next two years.

  9. Hedda

    What a beautiful story! Im expecting twins in early October (babies #2 & 3) and was getting pretty depressed with being told they would most likely be born early and possibly via c-section and that my options for having them were very limited. While a water birth does not appeal to me having them naturally is all I want.

    Thank you for sharing your positive twin birth story.

  10. Annie

    Hi Justine,

    Thank you for sharing your story! I’m looking to talk to more women who experienced a home birth with twins. I found out I was pregnant with twins a couple of weeks ago-6 months into my pregnancy. I never had a scan since my doctor explained I didn’t need one unless there was health reasons to do so. But my midwife thought I was big for the time of my pregnancy so she asked me to get one. Happy I did. 2 babies, 2 placentas and two sacs. I now have the option of a home birth with a private midwife or a hospital birth where I would have to put my foot down and remind them of my birth plan for a natural birth (don’t like that option).

    We already had a home birth in the water with our first baby and it was pretty amazing. It feels like going backwards to go to the hospital to birth these amazing babies. Both my private midwives are happy to attend my birth at home but baby #1 has to be head down. I live in Perth and here the program doesn’t allow twin birth at home and the birth center doesn’t want my “high risk pregnancy”.

    Any suggestions to help my babies be in the right position? I see an osteopath, acupuncturist, do yoga and/or swimming/ stretches almost every day. I’m a full time mum and sleep with my toddler everyday during her 2hours nap…I connect with them, love them and visualize as much as possible the birth I want…

    Thank you!


  11. Justine

    Hi Annie!
    Wow great news. I am happy to connect you with other twin HB Mums and also send you a twin resource folder that I have collated. Email me at

    You sound like you will birth beautifully!


  12. Anne-Marie


    Thanks for sharing your story. I’m pregnant with twins & wanting a VBAC. Seems like I won’t be ‘allowed’ to if I go through the hospital. Am trying to find midwives so I can have a HB. It’s funny that your 6 year old cut the cord, I am wanting my 4 year old to cut the cords, but thought people would think I was a little crazy.

    Beautiful story, thanks for sharing.

  13. Sarah

    Thanks Justine for sharing such a positive twin homebirth story…. My first two babies are due in December, if you know anyone that might support a homebirth in Toowoomba, please email me! Originally I would have liked a natural birth in a hospital but Im fairly positive that i wont find anyone to support me, I’m anxious and tired, with no ability to advocate for myself. There is even more perception of risk because this is my first pregnancy.

    Annie, I’m not sure if it is too late, but I accessed some really helpful info from to turn my bottom twin…

    xoxo Sarah

    • michelle

      Hi Sarah

      There are many people who can help you. You could contact Home Midwifery Association (Qld) –

      Naomi Waldren from HMA has a lot of info for twin births both in hospitals and at home – her email address is .

      In the Toowoomba area you also have the My Midwives practice who support women both in hospital and at home.

      Good luck!

  14. Jo

    Just wanted to share with you anxious twin mums-to-be that I had a magical twin birth (bubs 2 & 3) at my local public hospital! I too spent much of my pregnancy worried about the high levels of intervention that the medical system seem to think is “normal”. With some amazing support from the independent midwives in east freo I wrote a solid birth plan & when we arrived at hospital my partner made it very clear to everyone that we wanted it read & adhered to. We managed to have no doctors in the room for the labour & births, just 2 lovely midwives (after being told during ante-natal clinic appoointments there would be at least 4 doctors & up to 5 midwives). I also avoided being induced & went into labour naturally at 38+6. I too enjoyed a physiological thrid stage & avoided all the intervention that is in their clinical guidelines for twin birth (& the list is LONG!). So, it is possible to have an intervention-free twin birth in the hospital setting, but you & your birthing partner need to be very assertive to get what you want. I still get tingles thinking about how special the boys birth was & they are almost 2. Good luck & may natural twin births become the norm again. Soon.

Leave a Reply to “Twin Home Water Birth — Justine Caines”

    Site Credits: Mercury Rising Media
    © All rights reserved.